I lead with love, and I know it is not everyone’s jam, at least on the surface. My guess is that, reading the title question, you had a clear reaction. Maybe the idea of leading with love landed as an immediate YES: “Not only do I want to be led with love, I want to show up with love for the people I lead.” Or, your response might have been a visceral “no thank you.” The “no thank you” camp usually just wants to do good work, and they do not feel the need to be loved by their leaders, nor do they want to be responsible for loving those they lead. Sometimes they even feel that love in the workplace is inappropriate and makes managing performance difficult. I have not found this to be the case.
Having thought a lot about this, I am going to go out on a limb and say that, to be a great leader, you have to love the people on your team. I also believe that “leading with love” looks different for everyone. Many people assume leading with love is just a lot of warm fuzzies, but in reality, it has only one requirement. At a recent conference, a participant mentioned bell hooks's All About Love: New Visions, and it stuck with me. With this framing, love is a verb: not only wanting the best for someone, but taking direct, consistent action to help them grow and thrive. I believe this is what it means to lead with love.
Wanting the best for each person and taking direct, consistent action with that intention in mind is the best way I know to serve the individual while also serving the company. It means seeking to understand each person on the team and giving them opportunities to shine. It means paying attention to the whole person, including whether the pace of work leaves room for a life outside it. It means talking directly with them about performance, with the goal of maximizing their success. And even in situations where you must part ways, it means you have done everything you can to help them, and you recognize they might be better suited to succeed somewhere else.
Leading with love can be a force that elevates everyone’s performance, including the leader’s. This style of leadership pays dividends. It attracts (and keeps) top talent and creates an environment of creativity and fun. People who feel supported this way are more engaged in their work, less likely to burn out, and more likely to speak up early when something is wrong.
None of this happens by accident. It is hard work. Leading with love is not soft and mushy. It requires active intention and asks a lot from a leader. It is not an easy thing to want the best for each person, regardless of how they feel about you. Loving your team in this way does not necessitate love in return. It requires the leader to engage with their team while keeping part of their attention on the bigger picture. Leading with love doesn’t mean you can't make hard decisions. It means you make decisions with more consideration than just “What is good for the bottom line?”
I lead with love, but I don't expect everyone to want the warm fuzzies. The "no thank you" camp has a place on the team too. I recognize and honor each person’s preference, and I seek to be the one thing I am confident everyone desires: a leader who wants the best for them and is willing to take intentional action to help them succeed. It is not easy, but it sure can feel good.